What if I told you that the people who taught me that the modern State of Israel is the centerpiece of Bible prophecy also taught me that the Catholic Church is the Whore of Babylon? I’m not exaggerating. Back in my Calvary Chapel days in Southern California, I learned that the rebirth of Israel in 1948 started God’s prophetic clock. I also heard a pastor call the Catholic Church the “Whore of Babylon” in front of hundreds of people. At the time I didn’t see a connection. Now I do. In my last article on Christian Zionism I showed from Scripture and the Catechism that Jesus Christ fulfilled every promise God made to Israel, and that Christian Zionism is a severe theological error. Today I want to go one step further. Christian Zionism isn’t just mistaken. It’s anti-Catholic, and it has been from the very beginning.
Let me be clear up front. I’m not saying every Christian Zionist hates Catholics. Most of the Evangelicals I know are good people who love Jesus, and many of them are my friends. I’m talking about the system. A system that needs two peoples of God also needs a villain, and for five hundred years, that villain has been Rome.
IT STARTED WITH THE ANTICHRIST IN ROME

The Protestant Reformers didn’t invent Christian Zionism, but they laid the foundation for it. In the Smalcald Articles (1537), Martin Luther wrote that “the Pope is the very Antichrist, who has exalted himself above, and opposed himself against Christ.” A century later, the Westminster Confession of Faith (1646) put it into a creed: “nor can the Pope of Rome, in any sense, be head thereof; but is that Antichrist, that man of sin, and son of perdition, that exalteth himself, in the Church, against Christ and all that is called God” (WCF 25.6). Luther’s 1534 Bible even carried a woodcut from the Cranach workshop showing the Whore of Babylon wearing a papal tiara. That’s the image you see here and at the top of this article.
Now watch what happens next. The English Puritan Thomas Brightman (1562–1607) wrote commentaries on Daniel and the Apocalypse whose main object, according to the Dictionary of National Biography, was “to prove that the pope is that anti-Christ.” The same man became one of the first Christians to argue that the Jews would return to the Holy Land. His 1615 book was titled Shall They Return to Jerusalem Again? Historians call him a proto-Zionist. I call him the first Christian Zionist.
Did you catch that? From day one, the two ideas came as a package. Rome falls. The Jews return. The prophecy chart needed both halves.
FROM PURITAN PULPITS TO BRITISH POLICY
Fast forward to the 1800s. Lord Shaftesbury, the great Evangelical reformer, was a premillennialist who campaigned for the restoration of the Jews to Palestine. He helped persuade Lord Palmerston to send a British consul to Jerusalem in 1838, and in 1853 he described the region as “a country without a nation” in need of “a nation without a country.” The same Lord Shaftesbury denounced the Maynooth grant of 1845, which funded the training of Catholic priests in Ireland, and he fought the Catholic features of the Oxford Movement in his own Church of England. To be fair, he supported Catholic Emancipation. But a recent study in the Journal of Holy Land and Palestine Studies is titled, appropriately, “Nineteenth Century ‘Jewish Restorationism’ in the Service of Anti-Catholicism.”
That same year, 1853, a Free Church of Scotland minister named Alexander Hislop published The Two Babylons, which claimed the Catholic Church was a continuation of the pagan religion of Nimrod. Actual historians and reputable theologians (both Catholic and Protestant) regard Alexander Hislop’s The Two Babylons as 19th-century pseudohistory that collapses under a modicum of scrutiny. The book’s central claims — that Catholic doctrine and practice are merely a continuation of Babylonian paganism centered on Nimrod and Semiramis — rest on speculative etymologies, chronological impossibilities, misread secondary sources, and invented connections that no serious scholar of the ancient Near East or early Church accepts. Even Protestant writers who once popularized the work (most notably Ralph Woodrow) later retracted it after checking the footnotes against actual history. What remains is an anti-Catholic polemic that fails the most basic historical method. Remember that name — Hislop. It comes back.
Then there’s John Nelson Darby, the father of Dispensationalism. Before he went rogue and helped found the Plymouth Brethren, Darby was an Anglican curate in County Wicklow, Ireland, where he distinguished himself by persuading Catholic peasants to leave the Catholic Church. (I covered this more extensively in my book The Last Days.) Darby gave us the “two peoples” idea: an earthly Israel and a heavenly Church. I’ve written before that his system teaches both “rapture and rupture.” Most people know what the rapture is. The rupture is between the Church and Israel. Think about it. Which Church on earth claims most loudly to be the continuation of Israel, with a priesthood, an altar, a sacrifice and a Davidic prime minister in the office of Peter? That would be the Catholic Church. So in Darby’s system, she can’t be the Israel of God. She has to be the counterfeit.
AMERICA GETS THE SCOFIELD BIBLE
Darby’s ideas crossed the Atlantic and took over American Evangelicalism. William E. Blackstone, influenced by Darby, wrote the bestseller Jesus Is Coming (1878), and in 1891 he presented the Blackstone Memorial to President Benjamin Harrison, signed by men like John D. Rockefeller and J.P. Morgan, calling for a Jewish state in Palestine. To his credit, Blackstone wrote that it was “a great mistake” to call the popes the Antichrist. But in the same book he listed the “infallible Pope,” “image worship” and “the confessional” as the leaven that corrupted the Church.
Then came C.I. Scofield. His Scofield Reference Bible (1909) put Darby’s eschatological system right in the margins of the Bible itself. On the Abrahamic Covenant, Scofield wrote that “It has invariably fared ill with the people who have persecuted the Jew — well with those who have protected him. The future will still more remarkably prove this principle” (note on Genesis 15:18). That’s Christian Zionism in a nutshell. Now here’s his note on Revelation 18:2: “Two ‘Babylons’ are to be distinguished in the Revelation: ecclesiastical Babylon, which is apostate Christendom, headed up under the Papacy; and political Babylon.” He adds that “Ecclesiastical Babylon is ‘the great whore'” and identifies its center as “viz. Rome.”
So picture the average American Evangelical opening his Scofield Bible in the 1950s. In one margin, blessing the Jewish people is the key to the future. In another margin, the Catholic Church is the great whore. Same Bible. Same author. Same system.
THE TELEVANGELIST ERA
Here’s where it gets personal for me. Chuck Smith, founder of Calvary Chapel, wrote in his 1978 book End Times: A Report on Future Survival (p. 35) that the generation of 1948 would be the last, and that the world would end by 1981 at the latest. On his own recorded sermons he taught that Revelation 2:22 is “the indication that the Catholic Church would exist right up to the coming of Jesus Christ and the Rapture of the church.” I quoted that and more in my article Why I Left Calvary Chapel. I also told you how a pastor at my home church in Diamond Bar called the Catholic Church the “Whore of Babylon” before hundreds of people.
Hal Lindsey, a Dallas Theological Seminary graduate, did the same thing for the mass market. The Late Great Planet Earth (1970) tied the end of the world to the founding of modern Israel in 1948, and The New York Times called it the bestselling nonfiction book of the 1970s. Jerry Falwell, founder of the Moral Majority, wrote in The Fundamentalist Phenomenon (1981): “To stand against Israel is to stand against God.”
Then came Tim LaHaye and Jerry Jenkins with the Left Behind novels. In that series, the pope is raptured, but only after teaching a doctrine that “seemed to coincide more with the ‘heresy’ of Martin Luther” (Tribulation Force, p. 53). So, according to LaHaye and Jenkins’ fictional series, the pope is raptured (saved), but only after he effectively becomes a Protestant. The cardinal left behind becomes “Pontifex Maximus” of the Antichrist’s “Enigma Babylon One World Faith.” Carl Olson documented all of this. In his commentary Revelation Unveiled, LaHaye praised Hislop’s Two Babylons as a “masterpiece” and then said, “you may be inclined to think me anti-Catholic, but that isn’t exactly true; I am anti-false religion.” I’ll let you be the judge.
John Hagee founded Christians United for Israel (CUFI) in 2006. In 2008, when he endorsed John McCain, his past remarks about the Catholic Church created a national controversy. The New York Times reported that in his book Jerusalem Countdown he accused the Vatican of collaborating with Hitler. In his apology letter to Bill Donohue of the Catholic League, Hagee insisted he never meant those terms for the Catholic Church, but he admitted that calling the Catholic Church “the ‘apostate church’ and the ‘great whore’ described in the Book of Revelation is a rhetorical device long employed in anti-Catholic literature.” Credit where it’s due. He apologized. Later that month McCain rejected his endorsement over a different sermon.
And then there’s Robert Jeffress, pastor of First Baptist Dallas. On his radio program in 2010, he said that the “Babylonian mystery religion” infected the early Church, that its high priests wore fish-head crowns to worship the fish god Dagon, that the bishop of Rome inherited the title “Pontifex Maximus,” and that “today the Roman Catholic Church is the result of that corruption.” He called it “the genius of Satan.” If that sounds familiar, it should. Dagon’s fish-head mitre and the pagan Pontifex Maximus are straight out of Alexander Hislop’s Two Babylons from 1853. On May 14, 2018, Jeffress and Hagee both prayed at the opening of the U.S. Embassy in Jerusalem.
Do you see the thread? Luther and Westminster to Brightman. Puritan restorationism to Shaftesbury. Hislop to LaHaye to Jeffress. Darby to Scofield to Lindsey, Smith, Falwell and Hagee. Five centuries, one line, both anti-Catholic and Christian Zionist, joined at the hip.
The irony is that Christian Zionists frequently gaslight Catholics by branding those who reject their tenets as antisemites or Jew-haters, equating historic Christian teaching with ethnic malice. Sandra Hagee Parker (of CUFI), and daughter of John Hagee, has stated that “Replacement Theology” (the view that the Church fulfills the promises to Israel in Christ) is “misguided at best, and heretical at worst… nothing more than a false doctrine used to legitimize the world’s oldest hatred” and “the same strategy used by the Crusaders, the Spanish Inquisitors, Martin Luther, the Nazis, the KKK, and now the far right.” Her father, John Hagee, as stated above has long linked the Catholic Church to the “Great Whore” of Revelation and to historical antisemitism that allegedly shaped the Holocaust. Their argument is that refusal to affirm modern Israel as the ongoing fulfillment of an ethnic land covenant (and dual-covenant dispensationalism) is itself antisemitic. If you know history, they’re basically accusing every Christian, up until the Protestant Reformation, of antisemitism and Jew-hatred.
THE CATHOLIC ANSWER
Now here’s the Catholic answer. The Church is the Israel of God (Galatians 6:16). The Second Vatican Council taught that “the new Israel … is called the Church of Christ” (Vatican II, Lumen Gentium 9). This one Church “subsists in the Catholic Church, which is governed by the successor of Peter” [Catechism of the Catholic Church, paragraph 816 (CCC 816)]. St. Justin Martyr said it back in the second century: Christians are “the true spiritual Israel” (Dialogue with Trypho, 11).
So does that mean God is done with the Jews? Absolutely not. The Church calls the Jewish people “the first to hear the Word of God,” and says “the gifts and the call of God are irrevocable” (CCC 839). Nostra Aetate teaches, “Although the Church is the new people of God, the Jews should not be presented as rejected or accursed by God.” Read that sentence again. It says both things. The Church IS the new people of God, AND the Jews are not rejected. Christian Zionists quote the second half and skip the first.
In 2015, the Vatican’s Commission for Religious Relations with the Jews put the two-peoples idea to rest in The Gifts and the Calling of God Are Irrevocable. It says the Church “represents in him the fulfillment of the promises made to Israel,” and that the theory of “two different paths to salvation, the Jewish path without Christ and the path with the Christ … would in fact endanger the foundations of Christian faith.” The same document quotes the Holy See’s 1985 Notes: the State of Israel “should be envisaged not in a perspective which is in itself religious, but in their reference to the common principles of international law.” That’s not anti-Jewish. That’s just Catholic.
And it’s nothing new. When Theodor Herzl asked Pope St. Pius X to back Zionism in 1904, the pope told him, “We cannot give approval to this movement.” But he also said he had always been on good terms with Jews, that the Church prays for them, and “if you come to Palestine and settle your people there, we shall have churches and priests ready to baptize all of you.” That’s the Catholic position in a nutshell. Love the Jewish people. Pray for them. Invite them home to their Messiah. Just don’t baptize a foreign policy.
CONCLUSION
My Evangelical brethren, I’m not writing this to beat you up. I was one of you. I sat in those pews. I studied to be a Calvary Chapel pastor, and I even made little digs against Catholicism from the pulpit myself. I believed the 1948 clock and I believed Rome was Babylon. I didn’t realize I was believing a contradiction. Christian Zionism needs the Catholic Church to be Babylon, because if the Catholic Church is the Israel of God, then there’s no room for a second Israel with a second set of promises. It’s that simple. Strip away the prophecy charts and what you have left is five-hundred years of Protestant, anti-Catholic polemic wearing a Star of David.
You don’t have to choose between loving the Jewish people and loving the Church. The Church is where those two loves meet, at the altar of the Son of David. Come and see for yourself. The Catholic Church already recognizes your Trinitarian baptism as sacramental and will not repeat it. Thus, you are already joined to the Catholic Church (the New Israel of God) partially. If you want to dig deeper into where all these end-times theories came from, consider getting my book, The Last Days. Keep an open mind and pray about it. God bless.
Shane Schaetzel is an author of Catholic books and he is an Evangelical convert to the Catholic Church. His articles have been featured on LifeSiteNews, The Remnant Newspaper, Forward in Christ, and Catholic Online. You can read Shane’s books at ShaneSchaetzel.Com
